helloBARK! may earn revenue if you click the links featured on this page and make a purchase. Find out more
Tails.com vs Lily’s Kitchen
Tails vs Lily's Kitchen
helloBARK! staff
By helloBARK! staff
Updated on December 05, 2019

You might be ready to make a change to your dog’s diet.

If that’s the case, you’ll no doubt be doing your research on dog food delivery companies who can provide fresh meals for your pup.

Some dogs can be fussy when it comes to mealtime, turning their nose up at the grub in the dog bowl. This can be a frustrating and scary experience.

However, there’s an increasing number of dog food delivery companies who can provide pet parents with a new approach to dog meals.

In this article, we’re going to take a look at Tails and Lily’s Kitchen, who are two companies who provide fresh dog meals that can be delivered to your doorstep.

We’ll take a look at what recipes both companies have to offer, whether their meals are customized for your dogs needs, and what customers are saying about the feed.

This article will be broken up into the following sections:

Tails – The Basics

Website: Tails.com

Tails dry food (Photo: Tails)
Tails dry food (Photo: Tails)

Tails are a British dog food company that set about shaking up the dog food industry in the United Kingdom in 2013.

They’re determined to provide pet parents with a super-smart way to feed their dogs after relying on traditional brands in the past.

Tails require dog owners to enter the key details about their canines, such as age, breed, size, weight, activity level, body type and allergies.

In doing so, pet parents allow Tails to create customised dry food for your dog. You can also combine their customised kibble with wet food.

Every step of your Tails journey, you’ll learn a little more about dog nutrition thanks to their insightful information about your canine’s grub.

Your Tails delivery will come with a scooper that’s been created with your dog in mind to ensure you don’t underfeed or overfeed your pup. Their instructions are clear and concise.

Lily’s Kitchen – The Basics

Website: lilyskitchen.co.uk

Lily's Kitchen (Photo: Lily's Kitchen)
Lily’s Kitchen (Photo: Lily’s Kitchen)

Lily’s Kitchen are looking to adopt an eco-friendly approach to dog food. Everything they do has the greater good of the planet in mind.

They only use organic ingredients to ensure your dog is getting the best quality food when it comes to dinner time.

Unlike Tails, Lily’s Kitchen’s meals aren’t customised to your specific dog. However, they do have options for puppies, young adults and senior pooches.

They’ve given consideration to dogs with potential allergies. You can select recipes depending on whether you want beef, chicken, duck, goose, lamb, fish, pheasant, pork, turkey, venison and wild boar, They’ve also got an option for a single protein diet if that’s what you’re after.

Lily’s Kitchen meals have all been formulated with the input of vets, so you can have peace of mind knowing that experts have helped to create their organic recipes.

Unlike other dog food delivery companies, their meals are customised or pre portioned for your pup. However, they do provide guidelines on how much food you should give to your dog.

Things to consider when picking dog food delivery

• Ingredients – If you want to move away from traditional dog meals, you’ll want to know that you’re feeding your pup great ingredients that’ll benefit their health.

• Recipe Variety – For dog owners who have picky dogs like my Alaskan Klee Kai, you’ll want the option to mix up their meals thanks to a variety of different recipes.

• Expert input – It’s all very well using organic ingredients, but it’s equally important that the dog food is created by people in the know, such as vets or experts in canine nutrition.

• Packaging and Preparation – You don’t want to spend a little more on quality dog meals, only for your delivery to arrive damage or unspoiled. Similarly, you want mealtime to seamless if you’re spending more money.

• Ordering Experience – For dog owners who aren’t tech savvy, it’s important that the ordering experience is simple and straightforward.

• Price – While you can expect to pay a little more for these customised or organic dog meals, you shouldn’t have to pay over the odds with other expenses such as pet insurance to consider.

• Delivery schedule – If you’re planning to order from a dog food delivery company, you want to have flexibility to alter the schedule if possible.

Tails vs Lily’s Kitchen – Our Recommendation

Tails scooper (Photo: Tails)
Tails scooper (Photo: Tails)

So, who do we rate as the superior dog food option: Tails or Lily’s Kitchen?

We like both companies and you won’t go too far wrong if you choose either Tails and Lily’s Kitchen.

But we rate Tails as a better choice than Lily’s Kitchen.

We like how Tails have customised their dry food to your pet’s specific needs, as well as giving the option to add wet food.

Not only that, they provide pet parents with key information about the dog food to help encourage education and understanding.

Lily’s Kitchen offer a wide variety of recipes for dog of all ages. So whether you’ve got a puppy, adult dog or senior puppy, you’re sorted.

Whichever option you go for, Tails and Lily’s Kitchen will do a good job taking care of your canine’s diet.

What are customers saying about Tails and Lily’s Kitchen?

Tails have a five-star rating based upon over 19,000 reviews on Trustpilot. Let’s check out their stellar reviews!

One customer revealed how their food has helped with her canine’s stomach issues:

My dog was sick everyday or everyday he had a bad stomach. Since having his food from Tails, he has not been sick or had a dodgy stomach. This is not only great news for my furry boy but also excellent news for me. Trying Tails was the smartest cleanest move I ever made.

Another Tails subscriber gave the company a thumbs up all round:

Stella absolutely loves the biscuits (dry food) will happily eat them on their own even as a snack. Good selection of wet food. She absolutely wolfed each meal down at first and she’s a fussy, take it or leave kind of a girl. Delivered on time and always given to option to hold or change delivery date. We’ve been very happy using tails. Happy dog too.

Lily’s Kitchen have an average rating of 3.5 stars out of 5 on Trustpilot. However, they get 4.5 stars out of 5 on Feefo.com.

One pet owner called Matt was delighted with Lily’s Kitchen dog food after switching from a traditional brand:

I changed from using Bakers dry biscuit after the vet explained that this particular brand is full of additives and may not necessarily be good for my dogs health. I am now feeding her Lily’s dry and wet food. She literally eats it as soon as it is put down unlike previous brands which would be left for hours.

The owner of two Jack Russells explained why she’s willing to pay extra for Lily’s Kitchen:

I have used Lily’s Kitchen dog food for my two Jack Russells for many years. Both the wet food and the dry are excellent. ‘The Boys’ thrive on it. It is probably one of the more expensive dog foods but the quality is superb.

Anything else to consider?

If you’re looking for a discount for Tails or Lily’s Kitchen, we’ve got good news and bad news.

We couldn’t find a coupon code or discount offer for Lily’s Kitchen.

However, Tails are offering new customers a four-week trial for free with their first order. You can avail of this offer by clicking here and entering KLEEKAI at checkout.

Wrapping Things Up – Final Thoughts

Tails dog food (Photo: Tails)
Tails dog food (Photo: Tails)

So we’ve reached the end of our Tails and Lily’s Kitchen comparison article.

You can’t go too far wrong if you go for either dog food delivery options, but we feel Tails have a slight advantage.

We love that they customise their dog meals to meet your pup’s specific needs. So you can have peace of mind knowing their dry food is tailored to your precious pooch.

Not only that, they offer a range of wet food options, as well as some tasty dog treats.

Their customers service, whether it’s online, over the phone or in store, appears to be great judging by the customer reviews.

So while we like Tails and Lily’s Kitchen, we think Tails gets the nod here.