Spot & Tango vs A Pup Above Reviews

We receive free products to review and may earn commissions on purchases made through links on this page. Find out more
By helloBARK!
Updated on 5 July 2021

Have you decided it’s time to make a change to your dog’s diet?

There’s a growing shift amongst the human population to try to eat fresh, healthy and organic ingredients.

Why should we take such great care of our diet but feed our precious pooches dog food full of additives or nasties.

More and more companies are emerging that want to adopt a fresh approach to feeding our canine companions.

We’re big believers in dog food delivery companies given their meals are human grade and customised to your pet’s specific requirements.

Editor's note: The content on this website is meant to be informative in nature, but it should not be taken as veterinary, medical or professional advice. The content of our articles does not constitute veterinary advice. It’s always best to speak with your vet or a certified pet nutritionist before making any changes to your pet's diet or feeding routine.

In this article, we’re going to compare Spot & Tango and A Pup Above to see what both dog food delivery companies can offer pet parents.

We’ll take a look at the mantras of both companies, what recipes they offer, how their ingredients are sourced and cooked and what customers have to say.

You can check out updated guide on the best dog food delivery options in the USA available right now via this link.

Spot & Tango – The Basics


Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

Spot & Tango are looking to shake up the way you feed your dog with their fresh and healthy meals.

They’ve got an eco-friendly approach to the dog food delivery market, allowing you to feed your pup balanced and complete meals but not at the expense of our planet.

Spot & Tango list some compelling reasons to give their meals a try on their website, promising your dog will live better and longer.

Their ingredients are fresh and locally sourced, so there’s complete transparency about what goes into their meals, which are tailored to meet your dog’s needs.

We really like that Spot & Tango use 12 simple ingredients in their recipes so you can have complete confidence that your canine companion is eating real food.

If your pooch doesn’t like their meals, they’ve got a 100% Happy Pup Guarantee which means they’ll return your money.

You can have peace of mind knowing that they’ve recruited experts, such as animal nutritionists, to formulate their recipes.

One of the most appealing aspects of their service is their sustainable deliveries – they use eco-friendly packaging and insulation that dissolves in your sink.

Don’t forget if you’re a new Spot & Tango customer you can avail of our exclusive 50% discount off your first order when you click here.

A Pup Above – The Basics


A Pup Above (Photo:

A Pup Above (Photo:

A Pup Above create their meals using human-grade ingredients to ensure your dog is getting the necessary nutrients and vitamins.

Formerly called Grocery Pup, the company rebranded as A Pup Above in 2020.

Their website outlines that their meals are tested on humans, which means if it’s not good enough for us, your dog won’t eat it. Their recipes use non-GMO pesticide free vegetables and USDA-approved meat.

Perhaps their biggest selling point is the way in which their meals are cooked. They use a sous-vide method, which means your dog’s grub is cooked for two hours to ensure all the good stuff is locked in.

Like Spot & Tango, they’ve also consulted with vet nutritionists to ensure their meals meet your dog’s needs.

Unlike a lot of other companies, A Pup Above mould their meals into one pound patties. So you can be more economical with space.

However, their food isn’t pre portioned so you’ll need to ensure that you don’t overfeed your pup by following the guidelines provided on their website..

Things To Consider When Picking Dog Food Delivery

So you’re thinking about making a switch to these meals but you want to learn a little more about how it works.

• Ingredients – Dog food delivery companies use fresh ingredients in their recipes. Their meals use fresh vegetables and USDA-approved meat. There is complete transparency about what goes into the meals, so you won’t have to worry about any potential nasties.

• Recipe Variety – For pet parents who have picky eaters like my Alaskan Klee Kai, you’ll be able to understand the importance of having recipe variety. It’s vital to keep those fussy dogs guessing and motivated at dinnertime.

• Expert Input – You want peace of mind knowing that these meals are balanced and complete. In our experience reviewing dog food delivery companies, they recruit nutritionists and vets to help formulate their meals.

• Packaging and Preparation – You want the packaging to be able to protect the integrity of the meals en route to your home. However, it’s important that the packaging can be recycled, too. When it comes to serving your dog’s meals, you want a straightforward experience.

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out eight dog food delivery companies that can provide your pet with complete, balanced and fresh meals

• Ordering Experience – Not everyone will be computer whizz kids, so it’s important that these dog food delivery companies make the sign up process straightforward for those with limited technology experience.

• Price – You can expect to pay a little more for these meals given they use fresh ingredients and are tailored to meet your dog’s needs. Having said that, you shouldn’t be charged an excessive price for these meals.

• Delivery Schedule – If life gets in the way or you’ve got a vacation planned, it’s important that these companies allow you to be flexible with your delivery schedule.

Spot & Tango vs A Pup Above – Our Recommendation

So let’s get down to the crunch question: who do we recommend out of Spot & Tango and A Pup Above?

We rate Spot & Tango slightly ahead of A Pup Above based upon our experience with both companies.

We love Spot & Tango’s approach to their meals, sticking to 12 ingredients, which is simplistic and easy to follow.

Not only that, but their packaging is eco-friendly so you don’t have to improve your dog’s nutrition at the expense of the planet.

They’ve been in dog food delivery market since 2011, so they’ve got a lot of experience in the industry.

Having said all that, A Pup Above are still a good option for pet parents. Their sous-vide cooking method is a unique approach to the dog food delivery market.

While you won’t go too far wrong selecting either company, we rate Spot & Tango slightly above A Pup Above.

What Are Customers Saying About Spot & Tango And A Pup Above?

Spot & Tango have a review section on their website where they display customer testimonials. They’ve got a five-star rating.

One customer with a “historically” horrible eater was thrilled with their meals:

Kyrie has historically been a horrible eater and she loves Spot & Tango. when I take the package out of the fridge, she spins and dances around waiting for the food to hit her bowl! Thanks to you, meals are no longer stressful because she eats!

A customer called Mary gave Spot & Tango a big paws up having tried some of their competitors previously:

I have tried three other dog food delivery services. Spot & Tango is Millie’s favorite! She is so excited for her meals (and wasn’t with the others). Her coat looks amazing and she has no stinky breath! Two thumbs up to Spot & Tango!

RELATED: The eight best dog food delivery companies

A Pup Above have 78 reviews on their website from satisfied customers.

One picky Yorkie owner gave their food a five-star review:

This is by far the best home-delivery food for dogs that I have tried. My super picky dog absolutely loves all of the recipes, ordering is easy and the customer service is amazing. I even asked my canine nutritionist to review the ingredients and she said it was perfect. All around a win!

Another Yorkie was a big fan of A Pup Above – too:

I have been cooking for my finicky Yorkie for years and am so glad to finally have found something easier with my busy schedule that I feel is as healthy and yummy. I have tried lots of others and so far, this is the best! My dog loves it and she seems way more satiated, happier at mealtime and I swear her coat is shinier.

Spot & Tango Or A Pup Above Coupon Code Or Discount?

New Spot & Tango customers can get 50% off their first box, which is an offer exclusive to our readers on our website. To get your 50% discount, click here.

A Pup Above have a couple an offer available to new customers.

Our readers can can get 25% off their first A Pup Above order when they sign up to a subscription plan using the HELLOBARK25 coupon code at the checkout. Click here to subscribe now!

Anything Else To Consider?

We don’t recommend making an immediate switch to a new type of dog food. It’s generally recommended that you make a gradual transition.

If you change their diet too fast, your dog could suffer with some illness. For example, they could get diarrhea, vomiting or stomach problems.

This article doesn’t constitute veterinarian advice so we recommend contacting your local vet to get advice about making the transition.

Wrapping Things Up – Final Thoughts

We’ve reached the end of our Spot & Tango and A Pup Above comparison article.

Here at helloBARK!, we’re big fans of both dog food delivery companies but we believe Spot & Tango have the slight edge.

Spot & Tango’s meals exclude all artificial additives, preservatives, and fillers typically found in commercial kibble and canned dog food products.

They use simple ingredients that are visible, nutritious and of the highest quality. Their meals are packaged and delivered in a sustainable way, ensuring you and your dog have a green paw print.

If you’ve read our other articles on A Pup Above, you know that we consider them to be a good option in the dog food delivery market. So you won’t go wrong by selecting their subscription package.

However, we rate Spot & Tango slightly ahead of A Pup Above for the reasons set out above.

Don’t forget if you’re a new Spot & Tango customer you can avail of our exclusive 50% discount off your first order when you click here.

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out eight dog food delivery companies that can provide your pet with complete, balanced and fresh meals