Spot & Tango Vs Ollie Dog Food Reviews

We receive free products to review and may earn commissions on purchases made through links on this page. Find out more
helloBARK! staff
By helloBARK! staff
Updated on October 16, 2020

If we wouldn’t eat it, why should we expect our dogs to eat their food?

That’s attitude of a lot of dog food delivery companies that are providing Americans with a fresh way to feed their canine companions.

You may be accustomed to feeding your dog traditional dry food such as kibble that you bought in your local pet store or supermarket.

However, it’s not always clear what ingredients are used to create dry food for our dogs.

There’s a growing shift towards complete, balanced and fresh meals that are cooked and delivered by dog food companies in the USA.

Editor's note: The content on this website is meant to be informative in nature, but it should not be taken as veterinary, medical or professional advice. The content of our articles does not constitute veterinary advice. It’s always best to speak with your vet or a certified pet nutritionist before making any changes to your pet's diet or feeding routine.

In this article, we’re going to take a look at two of the leading dog food delivery subscription services: Spot & Tango and Ollie.

We’ll take a look at the recipes on offer, what customers say about these dog food companies as well as picking our favourite.

If you want to learn more about dog food delivery companies, you check out our updated guide via this link.

Spot & Tango – The Basics

Website: www.spotandtango.com

Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

Spot & Tango are an experienced dog food company considering that they’ve been in operation since 2011.

Their website explains that Spot & Tango offer balanced and complete recipes that have been formulated by veterinary nutritionists to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO.

We like that Spot & Tango only use 12 ingredients in each of their three recipes so you can have peace of mind knowing every ingredients that’s gone into your dog’s tasty meals.

Spot & Tango promise on their website that you won’t find any additives, fillers or nasties in their food. They only use fresh fruit and vegetables as well as locally sourced proteins.

They offer three different recipes: Turkey and Red Quinoa; Beef and Millet; Lamb & Brown Rice.

By entering key details about your furry pooch, Spot & Tango are able to customise their meals to meet your canine’s specific needs thanks to their proprietary algorithm.

Given the uncertainty surrounding what a post-covid world will look like, you’ll never have to go to the pet store or supermarket for dog food again as Spot & Tango will deliver your dog’s meals direct to your door.

Spot & Tango have an eco-friendly approach to dog food delivery. Their packaging is recyclable so you can leave a green paw print on the world.

Ollie – The Basics

Website: www.myollie.com

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie will deliver fresh and healthy meals to your door to take the stress out of feeding your dog.

They write on their website that they only use high quality meat, gently cooked fresh fruit and vegetables, superfoods such as chia seeds. Ollie underline that they don’t use any fillers in their recipes. Ollie add online that their meals are made in the USA .

You can also have peace of mind knowing that Ollie’s meals have been formulated by vets, or as they nicely put it: vet-crafted. They offer four different recipes: beef, chicken, turkey and lamb.

Like Spot & Tango, Ollie require some information about your canine companion to allow this dog food delivery company to tailor their meals to meet your pup’s specific needs, whether they need to gain or lose weight.

Ollie’s website promises two-day delivery thanks to their flexible and regular dog food deliveries. They add that shipping is always free.

Ollie do make some claims about the potential benefits of their custom dog meals, including more energy, less allergies, shinier coat and healthier weight. We’ll see what customers have to say a little bit later.

Things To Consider When Picking Dog Food Delivery

Copper and Skye the Alaskan Klee Kai tucking into some Nom Nom (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Copper and Skye the Alaskan Klee Kai tucking into some Nom Nom (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Perhaps you’re considering the prospect of making the switch to a dog food delivery company but you’ve still got some reservations. Here are some things that I considered before I decided to transition my Alaskan Klee Kai onto balanced and fresh meals.

• Ingredients – We all like transparency. So it’s important that dog food delivery companies use freshly and healthy ingredients, especially if you’re moving away from some traditional dog food options. We like when dog food providers are completely transparent about each ingredient in their recipes to provide health conscious pet parents with peace of mind.

• Recipe Variety – If you’ve got a fussy eater like me, you’ll know how stressful mealtime can be when your dog is showing no interest in their food. This can sometimes continue for days. Hopefully making the switch to a dog food delivery company will transform your picky pup into a food motivated dog. Having said that, it’s still nice to have some recipe variety.

• Expert Input – It’s nice to know that dog food delivery companies have hired experts to help formulate their meals. In doing so, you can feel good about your dog eating recipes thats have been created and fine-tuned by veterinarians with your canine’s best interests at heart.

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out five dog food delivery companies that can provide your pet with complete, balanced and fresh meals

• Packaging And Preparation – It’s important that your deliveries arrive in good condition, unspoiled. After all, you’re paying a premium price for these meals. It’s a nice touch if the packaging is recycable. When it comes to preparation, you want it to be seamless given your paying a little extra to take the hassle out of mealtime.

• Ordering Experience – Not every pet parent will be a tech genius living in Mountain View, although there are plenty of Californian pups eating these balanced and fresh meals. Therefore, it’s important that a dog food delivery company make it easy to sign up to their service, as well as being a pleasant experience.

• Price – You should be prepared to pay a little extra for these balanced and fresh meals. These companies are using high quality ingredients so it costs more to make your dog’s food. Hence why you’ll end up paying more than you would for pet food at the supermarket.

• Delivery Schedule – We all live hectic lives so it’s not always possible to be home to receive every delivery. It’s great when dog food delivery companies can offer some flexibility as well as ensuring your dog food stays frozen in the box.

Spot & Tango Vs Ollie – Our Recommendation

Alaskan Klee Kai Skye eyes some Nom Nom during a hike in California (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Alaskan Klee Kai Skye eyes some Nom Nom during a hike in California (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

We’ve come to decision time. Do we recommend Spot & Tango or Ollie?

There’s not a lot between these two dog food delivery companies so you’ll be in good hands irrespective of which one you decide to opt for.

We’ve tried both Spot & Tango and Ollie and both our taste testers enjoyed their balanced and complete meals despite being previously picky pups.

Spot & Tango only use 12 ingredients in their recipes, which is a simple approach to dog nutrition that we really like.

We like that they source all their ingredients from local suppliers so you can do your bit to support small businesses.

As an environmentally conscious pet owner, we like that Spot & Tango have taken extra steps to ensure their packaging is recyclable or biodegradable.

Ollie and Spot & Tango both use pre-portioned pouches to store their food so there’s no doubt about how much to feed your dog at mealtime.

To Ollie’s credit, they adopted this stress-free approach despite having previously used a customised scooper for their meals. It shows that they’re a dog food delivery company in tune with what their customers wants.

They do offer four recipes as opposed to Spot & Tango’s three-meal menu for American dogs.

Whether you go for Spot & Tango or Ollie, you won’t go too far wrong as we rate both of these companies highly.

What Are Customers Saying About Spot & Tango and Ollie?

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Spot & Tango don’t have any reviews on an independent review website like Trustpilot. They do have a review section on their website with some glowing reviews but we’d love to see some Google reviews or Trustpilot reviews of their recipes.

Megan detailed the benefits that her rescue dog has seen since making the switch to Spot & Tango.

We adopted a rescue dog who was struggling to gain weight. After trying different types of dry food we found Spot and Tango. She now gets excited for mealtime and has maintained a healthy weight. Her coat is so shiny and the change to her health is visible. We are so thrilled with the quality of this product and will be lifelong customers.

Mary gave a glowing review of Spot & Tango having previously tried some of their competitors.

I have tried three other dog food delivery services. Spot and Tango is Millie’s favorite! She is so excited for her meals (and wasn’t with the others). Her coat looks amazing and she has no stinky breath! Two thumbs up to Spot and Tango!

Elisa gave Spot & Tango a glowing review after their meals had a positive impact on her 11-year-old Greyhound.

I have a very picky 11-year-old retired racing Greyhound, so the challenge of finding high quality food she will actually eat that doesn’t cost a small fortune was a big one.

Ollie get 4 stars out of 5 based upon over 400 reviews on Trustpilot of which 71% are excellent and 12% are great.

Brenda revealed that her picky Yorkshire Terrier loves Ollie’s meals.

Our very picky Yorkshire Terrier loves Ollie food. Will she love it forever, I can’t say, but for me, I sure hope she does. The food is great, it arrives well packaged and frozen (even in Florida), and since it is a priority for my dog to have top of the line food, I ensure ample freezer space for it. Just add hot water and serve. High quality food that does not smell like dog food. My pup is thriving on it.

Ollie got another five-star review from a pet parent with a fussy dog.

I bought Ollie’s dog food because my dog Khalesi is a VERY picky eater and I was hoping she would like their dog food. Unfortunately, she doesn’t really care for it unless I feed it to her with a spoon. I have some to my other two dogs eat it like it’s the best thing they have ever had so I know the issue is with Khalesi and not myOllie’s dog food. Ollie has a very good dog food so give it a try. I just have a very picky eater.

Elena is a long-term customer with nothing but good things to say.

Barney loves his beef Ollie. I honestly love how prompt their service is and the food is always fresh. If their is ever any issues with the food, they replace it at no cost. I have been with Ollie for a while now and we are totally happy customers.

Spot & Tango and Ollie Coupon Codes or Discounts

Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

We don’t have a special offer for our readers for Spot & Tango. However, you can get 20% off your first order when you visit there website. So to avail of the discount, click here.

Ollie have a rather more tasty discount for first-time customers. If you’re ordering your first box of Ollie meals, you can get 50% discount. To get 50% off your first Ollie box, click here.

Anything Else To Consider?

If you’ve got a picky eater and you’re unsure whether they’ll like Spot & Tango or Ollie, we’ve got some good news.

Both of these dog food delivery companies offer a money back guarantee. Spot & Tango call it their Happy Pup Guarantee: if your dog doesn’t like their food, you’ll get your money back. Similarly, Ollie offer a 100% money back guarantee should your canine companion turn up their snout at the food.

We like that 1% of all Ollie’s revenue goes to their rescue organization partners, including the Sato Project. Their website explains that every meal your dog eats will contribute to the cause.

Generally it’s a good idea to speak to your vet before you decide to make a change to your dog’s diet. If you make the transition too quickly, you could risk upsetting your dog’s digestive system.

Wrapping Things Up – Final Thoughts

Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

Spot and Tango (Photo: Spot and Tango)

We’ve reached the end of our Spot & Tango and Ollie comparison article.

These are two dog food delivery companies who we consider to be amongst the leading options to feed your dog balanced, complete, fresh and vet formulated meals.

We really appreciate the simplicity of Spot & Tango’s recipes, using ingredients that you’ll recognise and be able to pronounce. There’s no nasties or fillers in their Turkey and Red Quinoa,
Beef and Millet and Lamb & Brown Rice recipes.

Spot & Tango use pre-portioned packaging so it takes the fuss out of mealtime. You just rip the packet open and serve the contents into your dog’s bowl.

Ollie have also opted for the pre-portioned pouches to ensure that you won’t have to mess around with scales and utensils at dinnertime.

They do offer four different recipes (beef, chicken, turkey and lamb) to ensure there’s something for every dog.

Whether you go for Spot & Tango or Ollie, you can have peace of mind knowing that you’ve opted for a healthier approach to your dog’s nutrition.

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out five dog food delivery companies that can provide your pet with complete, balanced and fresh meals