Ollie Vs A Pup Above Dog Food Reviews

We receive free products to review and may earn commissions on purchases made through links on this page. Find out more
By helloBARK!
Updated on 8 December 2020

Choosing the right dog food for your pup can be a confusing experience.

There are so many different options to choose from that it can be an overwhelming experience.

The emergence of dog food delivery companies have provided pet parents with a fresh option to feed their pooch.

These companies will cook fresh meals formulated by vets and deliver the food to your doorstep on a recurring basis.

Editor's note: The content on this website is meant to be informative in nature, but it should not be taken as veterinary, medical or professional advice. The content of our articles does not constitute veterinary advice. It’s always best to speak with your vet or a certified pet nutritionist before making any changes to your pet's diet or feeding routine.

This article will take a look at Ollie and A Pup Above, who are two dog food delivery companies helping out pet parents in the USA.

We’ll examine the different recipes that both companies offer for canines, what other customers are saying about the meals and whether they represent value for money.

Let’s take a close look at Ollie and A Pup Above, while seeing whether either make it onto our list of the best dog food delivery companies around right now.

Ollie – The Basics

Website: www.myollie.com

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie’s mission is to help pet owners feed their dogs in a smarter way.

This company cook fresh dog meals using human grade ingredients and fresh vegetables to ensure your canine is getting a healthy diet.

Ollie explain on their website that they don’t use any artificial ingredients, so pet owners can have peace of mind knowing only fresh and healthy products are used in their meals.

Dog owners are required to input their pooch’s information into Ollie’s questionnaire, which is easy to navigate thanks to helpful graphics.

Once you’ve put in some details such as age, weight, activity level and body type, Ollie will come up with a meal plan for your four-legged friend.

Ollie have four different recipes on offer: Hearty Beef Eats, Chicken Goodness, Healthy Turkey Feast and Tasty Lamb Fare.

Ollie’s deliveries arrive in a sturdy box with plenty of ice to keep the dog meals fresh.

They provide a custom scooper to ensure your dog is eating the appropriate portion, while they use special modified atmospheric packaging to seal their trays of dog food.

A Pup Above – The Basics

Website: www.pupabove.com

A Pup Above (Photo: apupabove.com)

A Pup Above (Photo: apupabove.com)

A Pup Above write on their website that they’re committed to creating better dog food for our dogs.

Formerly called Grocery Pup, the company rebranded as A Pup Above in 2020.

The Texan company have three core values that they highlight on their website: transparency, higher standard and convenience.

A Pup Above write online that they only use the best quality meat and the freshest vegetables to create their dog meals.

They’ve got three different recipes: Turkey Pawella, Porky’s Luau Stew and Bitchin’ Beef Stew.

Their philosophy is if humans wouldn’t eat it, then dogs shouldn’t eat it.

Like Ollie, A Pup Above require pet parents to enter some key information about their dog in order to allow the dog food delivery company to tailor their meals to meet your dog’s specific needs.

They’re food is delivered in one pound servings contained in resealable bags rather than pre-portioned pouches or pre-portioned containers.

A Pup Above customers can avail of a full meal plan or a half meal plan if you plan to slowly transition your pup onto their food.

Things To Consider When Picking Dog Food Delivery

• Ingredients – As dog owners, we want to know what ingredients are going into our pet’s food. As precious members of the family, pet parents want their dogs to be eating human grade ingredients to keep them happy and healthy.

• Recipe Variety – If you’ve got picky dogs like me, you’ll be all too familiar with the headache at dinnertime when your pups don’t want to touch their food. We like to see a variety of recipes to ensure dogs stay motivated at mealtime.

• Expert Input – The input of an expert can provide dog parent’s with peace of mind that these meals are formulated by people who know what they’re doing.

• Packaging and Preparation – If you’ve invested in a dog food delivery company, you want to make sure the meals arrived fresh and unspoiled. It’s also important that dishing up your dog’s food is a simple and time efficient process.

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out five dog food delivery companies that can provide your pet with complete, balanced and fresh meals

• Ordering Experience – Dog food delivery companies claim that their meals will be customized for your dog. If that’s the case, they’ve got to find a balance between getting the right information and information overload when dog owners fill out their sign-up questionnaires.

• Price – This is a premium service so pet parents will have to be prepared to pay a premium price. If you’re digging deep into your pockets to protect your dog’s health, you want to know it’s value for money.

• Delivery Schedule – Not everyone works from home, so it’s important that companies can be flexible with their delivery timings.

Ollie vs A Pup Above – Our Recommendation

So, which dog food delivery company do we rate higher, Ollie or A Pup Above?

There’s no doubt both companies do a solid job but we believe Ollie are a slightly better option for dog owners.

We found Ollie’s user experience to be fantastic on their website, making the inputting of information easy and uncomplicated.

A Pup Above, on the other hand, didn’t ask as many questions as Ollie, which made us feel like the latter’s meals would be more customized for our dogs.

They provide a custom scooper so you won’t overfeed your dog, unlike A Pup Above who provide a feeding guideline but no customised scooper or packets.

We like that Ollie provide you with four different recipes, in comparison to A Pup Above’s three meals.

Ollie allow dog owners to select different meals plans, ranging from 100%, 50% and 25%, so you can slowly switch your canine’s diet.

A Pup Above do provide for full and half meal plans – too.

While we don’t think you’ll go wrong if you choose A Pup Above, we believe Ollie have taken care of the fine details and that’s we rate them as the number one option here.

What Are Customers Saying About Ollie And A Pup Above?

Ollie have an average rating of 4.6 stars out of 5 based upon over 140 reviews on TrustPilot.com.

One customer raved about the Ollie’s dog food in a glowing five-star review:

My dogs love the Ollie food. I like having the fresh, good quality, nutritious, “homemade” dog food. The Ollie delivery comes packaged very well and it’s always still frozen which is important when you live in the dessert. I also like the new more compact packaging. I’ve recommended your product to my friends and family.

A rescue dog owner revealed how much their pup loves Ollie:

I rescued my dog a year ago. I fed him the same food he was fed at the Humane Society for about he first several months. Then I began switching him to Blue Buffalo which he stopped eating after the transition. Hated it. Tried Ollie and he LOVES eating again. Gets really excited. I’m happy he’s eating healthier food and not dried garbage.

A Pup Above’s website has a review section where they’ve got a five-star rating based upon 68 reviews. We were unable to find reviews on other unaffiliated websites.

A A Pup Above customer revealed how the meals helped her picky pup:

One Our pooch LOVES A Pup Above!! She was a finicky eater, we tried everything and had no success until we discovered GP. Great product, we get our shipment on time and as promised. We cannot thank you enough!

Another A Pup Above customer left a suggestion for the company in their four-star review:

My dog loved the food! Only thing I wish was different was the packaging, something easier to open & resealable would be great.

Anything Else To Consider?

New Ollie customers can get 50% off their first order.

All you need to do is simply click on this link and sign up to receive your 50 per cent discount at the checkout.

Wrapping Things Up – Final Thoughts

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

So we’ve reached the end of our Ollie vs A Pup Above comparison article.

There are a lot of things to like about both dog food delivery companies.

We appreciate that both Ollie and A Pup Above use human grade ingredients that are fresh and healthy.

Having said that, Ollie have an advantage over A Pup Above.

Ollie have a superior sign-up process, they’ve got four different recipes, they’ve got more flexible meal plans and their preparation process is easier.

However, A Pup Above are still a solid option for dog owners, but Ollie has the edge.

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out five dog food delivery companies that can provide your pet with complete, balanced and fresh meals