Nom Nom vs Ollie vs Pet Plate Reviews

We receive free products to review and may earn commissions on purchases made through links on this page. Find out more
helloBARK! staff
By helloBARK! staff
Updated on July 08, 2020

There’s lot of choice where feeding your dog is concerned.

You’ve probably been feeding your pet traditional dog food options in the recent past.

However, there’s an array of new options in the dog food market providing pet owners with a fresh alternative.

These freshly prepared dog meals are like home cooked meals but usually formulated by veterinarian nutritionists.

They tend to use high-grade ingredients and cook their meals in kitchen that meet human standards.

Editor's note: The content on this website is meant to be informative in nature, but it should not be taken as veterinary, medical or professional advice. The content of our articles does not constitute veterinary advice. It’s always best to speak with your vet or a certified pet nutritionist before making any changes to your pet's diet or feeding routine.

In this article, we’re going to look at Nom Nom, Ollie and Pet Plate, who are three of the biggest names in the dog food delivery market.

Nom Nom – The Basics

Website: nomnomnow.com

Copper and Skye the Alaskan Klee Kai with their first Nom Nom delivery (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Copper and Skye the Alaskan Klee Kai with their first Nom Nom delivery (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Nom Nom are a Californian company based in Oakland in the Bay Area.

They deliver freshly cooked dog meals direct to your doorstep to ensure your pup is getting a complete and balanced diet with minimal fuss.

Nom Nom write on their website that they only use restaurant-grade ingredients and their meals have been formulated by one of the USA’s leading veterinary nutritionists.

To start, you have to enter some key details about your pet or pets to give Nom Nom the opportunity to tailor their meals to meet their specific needs.

They offer four different recipes to ensure even the pickiest dogs will have something that satisfies their palette. Nom Nom’s meals include Porkalicious Potluck, Chicken Chow-Wow, Tasty Turkey Fare and Heartland Beef Mash.

Nom Nom’s meals are delivered to your doorstep in pre-portioned packets – that means you won’t need to worry about creating a mess at mealtime. You simply defrost the packets and empty the contents into your dog’s bowl.

Although they offer a premium service, Nom Nom are priced very competitively within the dog food delivery market. We feel their meals represent value for money, while they can provide valuable peace of mind.

Nom Nom have taken steps to be environmentally friendly since we first reviewed the company. Now they provide recycling instructions for your box, liner, meal packs, and everything else you find in your healthy shipments. So you can be eco-friendly feeding your dog.

Ollie – The Basics

Website: www.myollie.com

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie provide fresh and healthy dog meals (Photo: Ollie)

Ollie’s aim to help dog owners feed their precious pooches in a smarter way.

They can provide freshly cooked dog meals full of minerals and nutrients directly to your doorstep to make feeding your dog stress free.

Like Nom Nom, you won’t have to worry about any unwanted fillers or additives in their meals. They only use the very best human grade ingredients.

To help Ollie customise their meals to satisfy your dog’s needs, pet owners need to fill out their user-friendly questionnaire to provide some vital information.

They’ve also got four recipes to offer dog owners ready to make the switch to freshly cooked dog meals: Hearty Beef Eats, Chicken Goodness, Healthy Turkey Feast and Tasty Lamb Fare.

Ollie are a little different to the other brands featured in this article – they don’t use pre-portioned packaging. Instead, Ollie provide pet parents with a customisable scooper. So you won’t need to worry about overfeeding your pups.

Additionally, you’ll have less waste to worry about given you can reuse Ollie’s scooper. You won’t have to worry about having to dispose of lots of used food pouches.

Their meals are kept fresh upon their delivery to your home thanks to special modified atmospheric packaging. They offer great flexibility when it comes to scheduling deliveries. Customers can schedule meal deliveries for every one or two weeks.

Pet Plate – The Basics

Website: petplate.com

Pet Plate will offer a refund if your delivery arrives at room temperature (Photo: Pet Plate)

Pet Plate will offer a refund if your delivery arrives at room temperature (Photo: Pet Plate)

Pet Plate are another dog food delivery company looking to shake up the dog food market. Having started in New York City, Pet Plate deliver throughout the mainland states in the USA.

Their mission is to deliver “drool-worthy” meals to your precious pooch to keep them happy and motivated at dinner. They want to provide real food cooked fresh for your dog.

Pet Plate’s website writes that their meals are made with human-grade ingredients in a USDA facility. Every batch is tested for safety and flash-frozen to lock in freshness.

Again, you’ll to submit details about your dog’s age, breed, size, activity level and more to allow Pet Plate to customise their meals to meet your pet’s requirements.

Pet Plate have four recipes to offer dog owners: Barkin’ Beef, Chompin’ Chicken, Lip Lickin’ Lamb and Tail Waggin’ Turkey. They use a proprietary blend of minerals and nutrients in their recipes formulated by their vet expert.

Like Nom Nom, Pet Plate offer pre-portioned packets so dog owners won’t have to worry about getting utensils or weighing scales out of the cupboard. The stress is taken away.

Pet Plate’s meals are placed in recyclable, pre-portioned containers and packed in refrigerated, environmentally friendly boxes and delivered right to your door.

Things To Consider When Picking Dog Food Delivery

• Ingredients – If you’re going to make the switch to a dog food subscription service that delivers directly to your doorstep, you want peace of mind knowing that they use human-grade ingredients to enrich your dog’s diet.

• Recipe Variety – Dogs can be picky just like humans. For those fussy pups, it’s important dog food delivery companies offer variety so pet owners have an array of options to keep even the pickiest dogs motivated at dinner time.

• Expert input – We all like to see the input of experts when it comes to dog food. So it’s great to see companies such as Nom Nom have veterinarian nutritionists to formulate their meals to ensure your dog gets all the minerals and vitamins needed.

• Packaging And Preparation – It’s obviously crucial that your dog meals arrive in good condition and on time. So dog food delivery companies need to have good packaging practices. If you’re spending more money, you want feeding your dog to be simple and straightforward with minimal preparation required.

• Ordering Experience – Regardless of your age and technical abilities, dog food companies need to cater to everyone to make sure their sign-up process is easy to follow but detailed enough to get all the necessary information to customise their meals.

• Price – You may be willing to pay a little extra for your dog’s food, but you don’t want to be overcharged. Just because the meals are freshly cooked with human-grade ingredients doesn’t mean you should be overcharged.

• Delivery Schedule – Life can get in the way sometimes. Therefore, dog food delivery companies need to be flexible when it comes to delivering your pup’s meals at a time that works for you.

Nom Nom vs Ollie vs Pet Plate – Our Recommendation

Alaskan Klee Kai Skye eyes some Nom Nom during a walk in San Fransisco (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Alaskan Klee Kai Skye eyes some Nom Nom during a walk in San Fransisco (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

It’s the moment of truth. Who do we recommend: Nom Nom, Ollie or Pet Plate? Well, all three companies provide good options for pet parents.

We particularly like Nom Nom and Ollie.

Nom Nom proved to be a big hit with my dogs and I appreciated how easy it is to change recipe month to month so I could keep my fussy Alaskan Klee Kai excited about their grub.

Their meals are pre portioned so I didn’t have to worry about creating a mess when it was feeding time. I simply defrosted their packets, ripped them open and served in their bowl.

We like how Ollie provide a customisable scooper that you can reuse. This cuts down on packaging, which can be a big consideration if you live in a city with limited refuse options.

It’s great that Ollie go to great lengths to make sure their food is human-grade quality, so you can have peace of mind knowing your canine is eating a balanced diet.

They’re meals were a big hit with our taste tester Mercer. The seven-year old couldn’t get enough of his tasty grub.

Although we rank Pet Plate third in this comparison article, we still believe you won’t go too far wrong if you decide to go with this company.

What Are Customers Saying About Nom Nom, Ollie And Pet Plate?

Nom Nom have an average rating of 4.6 stars out of 5 based upon over 900 reviews on independent website Trustpilot.

One pet parent felt Nom Nom was worth the investment:

I was hesitant to try this because of the cost. I’m glad I did. My dog loves it. He gets so excited when I open the fridge. He was eating kibble before this and he was starting to get chubby and lazy. With this food, I’ve noticed his energy level is back up and he’s doing much better. This was a great decision to switch to this food.

A Goldendoodle owner gave their food a glowing review:

I tried this food after a picky Goldendoodle turned away from many other foods. He eats every bite now and our lab mix has lost a little weight. Yes, a little more expensive per month but nothing ends up in the garbage now and two happy pups!

Ollie gets 4.4 stars out of 5 based upon over 145 reviews on independent website Trustpilot.

A dog owner revealed how Ollie helped her pup with a sensitive tummy:

I love this food and this company ! After years of sensitive stomach issues, one week on Ollie beef formula, he became more alert and more active. We are about 4 weeks in and his coat is beautiful, his eyes are clear, his breath is great and so are his ears! I love the recyclable products and the customer service is wonderful! I feel so good about the quality ingredients I am feeding our little guy.

One pet parent revealed just how good Ollie’s packaging is:

My dogs love the Ollie food. I like having the fresh, good quality, nutritious, “homemade” dog food. The Ollie delivery comes packaged very well and it’s always still frozen which is important when you live in the dessert. I also like the new more compact packaging. I’ve recommended your product to my friends and family.

We couldn’t find any Pet Plate reviews on independent websites. They’ve got an average rating of 4.69 stars out of 5 based upon over 250 reviews on petplate.com.

A lady called Eileen left a promising review of Pet Plate:

Joon was having digestive issues before starting Pet Plate. We had concerns about the ingredients in the food we fed her before Pet Plate. Now we feel good about what she’s eating and she loves it too!

Another dog owner called Renee was impressed with Pet Plate’s service:

Pet Plate offers an introductory “test it out” and that made it easier for me to make my decision as they also will refund you your money if your doggie doesn’t like it. Sky is a picky eater and loves her Barkin’ Beef recipe! I love that the meals are balanced and ready to serve.

Nom Nom, Ollie And Pet Plate Discounts

We did thorough research to see if we could find any discounts or coupon codes for helloBARK! readers.

While we were unable to find any offers for Ollie and Pet Plate, we do have a tasty discount for Nom Nom.

If you’d like to give Nom Nom a try, you can get a 50% discount off your first order by clicking this link.

Once you’ve placed your first Nom Nom order, the 50% discount should be automatically applied at the checkout.

Wrapping Things Up – Final Thoughts

Alaskan Klee Kai Skye tucks into some Nom Nom during a hike in California (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Alaskan Klee Kai Skye tucks into some Nom Nom during a hike in California (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

So we’ve reached the end of our comparison article featuring Nom Nom, Ollie and Pet Plate.

We really like Nom Nom’s recipes and our dogs were quick to devour their meals during our trial.

They’re packaging is simple to use given it’s already pre portioned so there’s minimal fuss at dinner time.

Ollie provide an alternative method of feeding your dog by using a scooper to make sure pet parents can enforce portion control.

Like Nom Nom, they offer four different recipes to satisfy fussy dogs.

We believe Nom Nom and Ollie are two of the best options in the dog food delivery market at the moment based upon our own experiences.

However, even if you go for Pet Plate, you won’t be going too far wrong with their tasty dog meals.

• For more information and to order Nom Nom, visit: nomnomnow.com

• For more information and to order Ollie, visit: myollie.com

• For more information and to order Pet Plate, visit: petplate.com