KatKin Vs Untamed Cat Food Reviews

We receive free products to review and may earn commissions on purchases made through links on this page. Find out more
By helloBARK!
Updated on 21 September 2023

Are you ready to make a change to your cat’s food but you can’t decide between KatKin and Untamed?

They’re two of the leading fresh cat food brands in the UK who are offering British pet owners a fresh alternative to dry food or wet food.

There’s no escaping the fact that cats can be fussy and you may be struggling to find cat food that your feline friend will consistently eat.

We’ve reviewed KatKin and Untamed cat food to shed light on these fresh cat food brands as pet owners continue to embrace a fresher diet for their felines.

In this comparison article, we’re going to take a closer look at KatKin and Untamed to see how these fresh cat food brands compare.

We’ll take a look at how Katkin and Untamed work, give our verdict based upon the experience of our taste tester Mo the Ragdoll and highlight some customer reviews.

With the introduction out of the way, let’s start our KatKin Vs Untamed Cat Food reviews.

Who Are KatKin?

Website: katkin.com

Maurice the Ragdoll with his KatKin delivery (Photo: hellobark.com)

Maurice the Ragdoll with his KatKin delivery (Photo: hellobark.com)

KatKin are one of the leading fresh cat food companies in the UK.

KatKin believe that cats were born to eat meat so they’ve created a range of recipes that are 100% fresh food made to provide British cats with balanced and complete meals to live a happy and healthy life.

Their website explains that KatKin uses 100% human-quality meats that are gently cooked and frozen for freshness before being shipped direct to your door.

You can have peace of mind that your cat is eating fresh food catered to their specific needs seeing as a board-certified vet nutritionist has designed their eight recipes.

By filling out their sign-up questionnaire, KatKin will ensure your cat’s daily nutritional needs are met whether you’ve got a kitten or a senior cat.

KatKin don’tuse as grains, fillers or preservatives in their food because they believe in putting cats first. That’s why they gently cook their meals to aide the digestion process!

Their website claims that 93% of cat owners see their cat’s health improve after making the switch to KatKin food – promising better digestion, more energy and playfulness, shinier and thicker coats and a healthier weight.

If you’ve got a fussy feline, you’ll be excited to learn that KatKin offer eight different recipes so there’s plenty of choice.

Who Are Untamed?

Website: untamedcatfood.com

Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

Untamed are another fresh cat food brand in the UK who promise your cat will go wild for their whole meat recipes.

Their recipes are formulated by vets so you can feel confident that your feline friend is eating human-grade ingredients and only whole meats.

Untamed write online that domestic cats do best eating real meat so they’ve made sure to pack their recipes with fresh, human-grade meats that are gently steam-cooked to lock in nutrients and flavour.

Just like KatKin, Untamed don’t use animal derivatives, no vegetable proteins, no grains and no sugars.

If you’ve got a cat who needs to lose some weight or you’ve got a senior cat that isn’t particular active, Untamed can tailor your cat’s meal plan accordingly.

They offer a customized service just like KatKin but you will have to fill out their sign-up questionnaire to allow Untamed to tailor your feline’s meals.

KatKin Vs Untamed: Who Do We Recommend?

Maurice the Ragdoll with his KatKin delivery (Photo: hellobark.com)

Maurice the Ragdoll with his KatKin delivery (Photo: hellobark.com)

We’ve reached the key part of this comparison article. So who do we recommend? Well, we sent our reviewers Jess and Joe plus their Ragdoll cat Mo some KatKin and Untamed to try. Here’s their feedback:

“KatKin feels the most tailor made and the portions were in line with Mo’s breed and size. The questionnaire was thorough and the leaflet included in the initial delivery was very informative and explained the transitional process. It was a nice touch that Mo’s name was on the delivery box.

“The food was frozen which feels super fresh and the extremely high meat content is evident in the food. Joe and I really liked the chicken sprinkles included in the delivery which we were able to put on top of Mo’s fresh meals. Mo loved the sprinkles and we’d consider buying these as a standalone product.

“The packaging is very slimline and easy to stack in the freezer. We also appreciated that the packaging is recyclable.

“The only cons were the smell when left out of the fridge or freezer for some time. Mo is a slow eater so if the food was left out all day, there would be a smell when we arrived home.

Maurice with his Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

Maurice with his Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

“Untamed came out on top, although it was close. We felt that Untamed is slightly less tailored to your cat but I am aware there is still a questionnaire process. The portions are slightly smaller, so good if your cat also has kibble left out for grazing like Mo.

“We think Untamed has been Mo’s favourite food so far. We also think the portion size for him is better- much smaller than KatKin’s, so a lot less waste. Food looked meaty and appetising. Although it still has some jelly, the jelly is well coated throughout encouraging him to eat more, not just lick the jelly off. There were three flavours in our box, his favourite was the chicken.

“The food comes in tins, so if you have a small freezer, this is the better option for storage. The food is very meaty, you can visibly see shredded chicken and actual shrimps in the food. This went down very well with Mo. Chicken flavour his absolute favourite, good for humans as not very smelly either!

“I would say this is a good hybrid between natural and more processed tin food so the transition was easier for him.”

Overall, Jess and Joe preferred Untamed to Katkin. A big factor was the appearance and smell of the food as well as the convenience of storing Untamed in the cupboard rather than the fridge or freezer.

Mo also seemed to prefer Untamed over KatKin – the portion size suited Mo and there was less waste with Untamed than KatKin.

So the cat owners opted for KatKin but the cat opted for Untamed!

What Do Cat Owners Have To Say About KatKin and Untamed?

KatKin's customized cat food (Photo: hellobark.com)

KatKin’s customized cat food (Photo: hellobark.com)

KatKin have an average rating of 4.1 stars based upon over 5,000 reviews on Trustpilot.

Sabina discussed why she feels good feeding KatKin to her cat.

Our cat has always been on Katkin from his breeders. We have had him over 6 months now. He eats well, his coat is beautiful, and his waste doesn’t smell bad. You fill in a questionnaire and the meals is designed for your cat’s needs and stage in life! We are happy we feel we are giving him the best food for a healthy life. (No nasties, no cereals or vegetables. A good natural cat diet.)

Joanna wouldn’t hesitate to recommend KatKin to other cat owners.

KatKin is a fantastic cat food subscription service. Their mission to educate cat parents about the nutritional needs of their feline companion, is very close to my heart. The quality of their meals is exceptional, featuring natural, high-grade ingredients that support my cat’s health. The customized meal plans are tailored to my cat’s specific needs and preferences, ensuring he receives the right nutrients in every meal. The convenience of doorstep delivery is a game-changer, and the eco-friendly packaging is a huge plus. Overall, I highly recommend KatKin to all cat owners who want the best for their furry friends.

Maurice with his Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

Maurice with his Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

Untamed have a far superior score on Trustpilot, receiving 4.8 stars based upon 1,000 reviews.

Tempeste believes Untamed’s cat food is unparalled.

Percy has traditionally been quite a fussy eater. Until Untamed. He loves it – particularly the tuna variations, so it’s great that we can tailor his box to include lots of fish! The food looks and smells super fresh – quite honestly, it looks much nicer than the tuna you get in a can sold for human consumption! We’ve only been getting Untamed for a couple of months but so far, each new month’s box has arrived with perfect timing. We’re impressed.

Jonathon explained that Untamed looks fresh and his cat loves the food.

I’ve really liked what Untamed offer and so does my cat Simpson! It’s quite clear as soon as you open the can it is very high quality meat and freshly canned. My cat is a grazer and will want to come back later rather gobble down straight away. The food stays fresh and appetizing but the main point is the peace of mind that your cat is eating best food possible rather indeterminate rubbish.

Anything Else To Consider?

It’s a good idea to speak to your vet before you decide to make a change to your cat’s diet. It’s important to slowly transition your feline friend to their new meals. KatKin and Untamed provide information in your first delivery box on how to successfully transition to their food.

Wrapping Up – Our Final Thoughts

Maurice with his Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

Maurice with his Untamed Cat Food (Photo: hellobark.com)

We’ve reached the end of our KatKin vs Untamed comparison article.

It’s great that these two cat food brands are offering a fresh and healthy approach to pet food nutrition to give British cat owners the opportunity to make a change for good.

You won’t go wrong with KatKin or Untamed because they use high-quality ingredients in vet formulated recipes that are gently cooked and shipped direct to your door.

Our taste tester Mo preferred Untamed over KatKin and his owners Jess and Joe slightly preferred the experience of feeding Untamed to Mo thanks to the quality of the food and the convenience of tins.

So if you prioritising taste, you may want to start your fresh cat food journey with Untamed.