Butternut Box vs Lily’s Kitchen Reviews

We receive free products to review and may earn commissions on purchases made through links on this page. Find out more
helloBARK! staff
By helloBARK! staff
Updated on July 17, 2020
Expert Content

You’re thinking about making the switch to a dog food delivery company.

There are quite a few options for dog owners in the UK and Northern Ireland if you’re looking to adopt a fresh approach to pet nutrition.

Some traditional dog food brands aren’t completely transparent about what goes into their meals, omitting potential additives and nasties.

We love dog food delivery companies because they only use fresh ingredients that are of human-grade quality.

So you can have peace of mind knowing that your canine companion is getting a complete and balanced diet.

Editor's note: The content on this website is meant to be informative in nature, but it should not be taken as veterinary, medical or professional advice. The content of our articles does not constitute veterinary advice. It’s always best to speak with your vet or a certified pet nutritionist before making any changes to your pet's diet or feeding routine.

In this article, we’re going to take a look at Butternut Box and Lily’s Kitchen, examining their recipes and customers reviews before delivering our verdict.

Butternut Box – The Basics

Website: www.butternutbox.com

Alaskan Klee Kai Copper with his Butternut Box delivery (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Alaskan Klee Kai Copper with his Butternut Box delivery (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Butternut Box are one of the leading dog food delivery companies in the UK. They’re looking to help dog owners give their best friend their best meal.

This British company are on a mission to put the food back into dog food, so they’ve got a fresh approach unlike traditional options you may be accustomed to giving your pup.

Butternut Box explain on their website that they only use ingredients that you can see and say, so there’s complete transparency giving your peace of mind that your canine companion is eating healthy and fresh.

They go on to say that their meals are vet approved, grain free and made in the UK. They add that their recipes are complete and gently cooked to perfection.

Their recipes are comprised of 60% meat and 40% vegetables. You’ve got a choice between Chow Down Chicken, Beef It Up, Wham Bam Lamb and Gobble Gobble Turkey.

Pet parents will need to enter some key details about their dogs to allow Butternut Box to tailor their meals to meet your pup’s specific requirements.

They store the meals in perfectly-portioned pouches, which are frozen to lock in the freshness and delivered in insulated boxes at a time that suits you.

Feeding your dogs will never have been easier. You simply rip open the pouch and serve into the bowl.

We love that Butternut Box have an eco-friendly approach to their packaging. You can recycle their box, ice packs and insulation so you won’t be feeding your dog these healthy and tasty meals at the expense of the planet.

Lily’s Kitchen – The Basics

Website: www.lilyskitchen.co.uk

Lily's Kitchen (Photo: Lily's Kitchen)

Lily’s Kitchen (Photo: Lily’s Kitchen)

Lily’s Kitchen have created proper food for pets that are full of proper meat and vibrant vegetables.

They explain on their website that they believe that our pets are family so we should be feeding them natural recipes that will do them good.

Lily’s Kitchen only use organic ingredients so you know that your dog is getting the best quality food when it comes to dinner time.

Their meals aren’t customised or tailored to your dog’s unique needs. However, they do have different ranges for pups, adult dogs and senior canines.

You can find an array of options with regards to recipes. These include beef, chicken, duck, goose, lamb, fish, pheasant, pork, turkey, venison and wild boar.

Unlike Butternut Box, Lily’s Kitchen’s meals are’t pre-portioned so you’ll need to follow their guidelines on how much to feed your dog to make sure you don’t overfeed.

Things To Consider When Picking Dog Food Delivery

If you’re thinking about making the switch to a dog food delivery company, here are some additional things to consider and weigh up.

• Ingredients – These companies use natural ingredients, so you don’t have to worry about any nasties going into their food. They use the freshest fruit and veg as well as high quality meat in their meals.

• Recipe Variety – For dog owners who have picky pups like me, you’ll know how important it is to have some recipe variety. That’s why a range of options is great for pet parents with fussy eaters.

• Expert Input – You want to know that these meals have had input from experts. Most dog food delivery companies call upon an army of vet nutritionists to ensure their meals are balanced and formulated to perfection.

• Packaging and Preparation – If you’re ordering these meals and paying a little extra, you want the process of feeding your dog to be easy and efficient. Most dog food delivery companies will use pre-portioned packaging.

• Ordering Experience – If you’re a bit of a technophobe, it’s important that the process of ordering is easy with simple steps to follow.

• Price – Let’s be real. These dog meals don’t come cheap but you’re paying a little more for healthier ingredients. The long-term goal is to save money with less trips to the vet. This certainly worked out for me.

• Delivery schedule – If you’re planning to order from a dog food delivery company, you want to have flexibility to alter the schedule if possible.

Butternut Box vs Lily’s Kitchen – Our Recommendation

Alaskan Klee Kai Copper with his Butternut Box delivery (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

Alaskan Klee Kai Copper with his Butternut Box recipes (Photo: @lifewithkleekai / Instagram)

So we’ve got the crux of the article – who gets our recommendation?

We are big fans of Butternut Box so we’d recommend them to pet parents in the UK.

We love that they use fresh and healthy ingredients to comprise their meals. You know that all your dog’s meals are comprised of 60% meat and 40% vegetables.

Their meals are store in pre-portioned pouches so there’s no uncertainty about how much you should feed your dog. They’ll get the right amount every time.

As a pet owner who cares about the health of our planet, I really appreciated that Butternut Box have gone to great lengths to adopt a sustainable approach to their dog food delivery service.

Having said that, Lily’s Kitchen is still a good option for dog owners. We just appreciate how Butternut Box meals are customised to your dog and come ready-to-serve.

So Butternut Box is our recommendation between these two British dog food delivery companies.

What Are Customers Saying About Butternut Box And Lily’s Kitchen?

Butternut Box get a glowing 4.9 stars out of 5 based upon nearly 5,000 reviews on independent review website Trustpilot.

A Spaniel owner was delighted with Butternut Box’s overall service:

Butternut Box provide such yummy, healthy food for my beloved spaniel Pixie. They are always polite, and go out of their way to be helpful in customising your needs. Best company I’ve dealt with in many years. Well done Butternut Box!

Another customer felt Butternut Box was great and represented value for money:

Excellent food! My dog is usually not interested in her food but she loves this! I’ve tried to replicate making similar myself but can’t do it for the same price. Very pleased all round.

Lily’s Kitchen have an average rating of 2.9 stars out of 5 on Trustpilot. They’ve received quite a few negative reviews but here are some of the positive ones.

A Staffy owner was thrilled with Lily’s Kitchen’s food:

Our 14 year old staffing cross has always had problems with food sensitivity, sometimes not wanting to eat her food at all but since giving her Lily’s Kitchen wet dog food she has been thriving. She eats her food happily and enthusiastically every day.

The owner of two Jack Russells explained why she’s willing to pay extra for Lily’s Kitchen:

I have used Lily’s Kitchen dog food for my two Jack Russells for many years. Both the wet food and the dry are excellent. ‘The Boys’ thrive on it. It is probably one of the more expensive dog foods but the quality is superb.

Butternut Box and Lily’s Kitchen Coupon Codes And Discounts

We’ve got an exclusive offer that we can give to helloBARK! readers who are first time Butternut Box customers. You can get 75% off your first Butternut Box order by clicking here.

We couldn’t find a coupon code or discount offer for Lily’s Kitchen.

Wrapping Things Up – Final Thoughts

We’ve reached the end of our Butternut Box and Lily’s Kitchen comparison article.

While we like both companies, Butternut Box are the superior dog food delivery company.

My dogs were obsessed with their food, which is something I’m not accustomed to. My Alaskan Klee Kai are usually fussy eaters but they loved these freshly prepared meals.

I loved how easy it was to serve – too. Once my delivery arrived, I only had defrost one pouch, rip open and serve directly into their dog bowls. It was minimal fuss!

Butternut Box have great customer reviews with nearly 5,000 people vouching for the quality and positive impact of their complete and balanced dog meals.

So if you’re thinking about making a change to dog’s diet, we recommend you consider Butternut Box for their freshly prepared and lovingly cooked dog meals.

To learn more or to get 75% off your first Butternut Box order, visit: butternutbox.com

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out the top three leading dog food delivery companies in the UK to help you keep an eye on your pets