A Pup Above vs The Farmer’s Dog Reviews

We receive free products to review and may earn commissions on purchases made through links on this page. Find out more
By helloBARK!
Updated on 23 April 2021

There are lot of dog food options on the pet market.

With so much choice, it can be difficult to decide which brand or type of dog food is the best option for your four-legged friend.

Over the past four or five years, dog food delivery companies have provided a fresh alternative for pet parents.

These companies create recipes using fresh ingredients that are tailored to your dog’s specific requirements.

Editor's note: The content on this website is meant to be informative in nature, but it should not be taken as veterinary, medical or professional advice. The content of our articles does not constitute veterinary advice. It’s always best to speak with your vet or a certified pet nutritionist before making any changes to your pet's diet or feeding routine.

In this article, we’re going to take a look at A Pup Above and The Farmer’s Dog, who are two dog food delivery companies in the USA.

We’ll take a look at the different recipes that both companies offer, the packaging they use and what customers are saying about their meals.

You can check out our updated guide to the best dog food delivery companies operating right now via this link.

A Pup Above – The Basics

Website: www.apupabove.com

A Pup Above (Photo: apupabove.com)

A Pup Above (Photo: apupabove.com)

A Pup Above use human-grade ingredients to create complete and healthy recipes for your four-legged friends.

Formerly called Grocery Pup, the company rebranded as A Pup Above in 2020.

The company write online that they use quality meat with fresh vegetables to give you peace of mind that your dog is only eating the best possible ingredients.

Their website explains that they source non-GMO, pesticide free vegetables and USDA meats from farms across the USA.

Their dog meals are tested on humans and are made in a USDA human food facility, applying the same safety and quality standards as human food.

A Pup Above explain online that they cook their meals sous-vide, which is a unique selling point. They do this to retain nutrients and boost flavor. They cook the meals for almost two hours to ensure all the nutrients are retained.

They’ve got a vet nutritionist to ensure they’re healthy, delicious and nutritionally balanced meals.

A Pup Above provide environmentally conscious pet parents with the opportunity to trace how their batch of dog food was made from farm to bowl, providing complete peace of mind that the ingredients in your dog food were responsibly sources and free from pesticides.

The Farmer’s Dog – The Basics

Website: www.thefarmersdog.com

Dog eyes cooked meal (Photo: The Farmer's Dog)

Dog eyes cooked meal (Photo: The Farmer’s Dog)

The Farmer’s Dog believe if you’re eating healthy, your dog should be to.

Their website goes on to add that they aim to provide a service that delivers balanced, freshly made pet food with simple recipes, guided by science, and driven by love.

They use real food so that means human-grade meat and vegetables in simple recipes designed for dogs. You won’t have to worry about meal, preservatives, brown pellets or use any label tricks.

Like A Pup Above, their meals are created in a USDA kitchens. Their meals are vet approved and exceed industry standards for dogs.

Dog owners will receive a personalized plan for their precious pooch, which means your pup’s meals are tailored to their specific needs.

The Farmer’s Dog aim to deliver your meals within days of cooking, ensuring that your canine is ingesting healthy food that is good for them.

Things To Consider When Picking Dog Food Delivery Company

If you’re thinking about making a switch to dog food delivery companies, here are some things to consider.

• Ingredients – If you’re making the switch to a dog food delivery company, you want to be certain that your pooch is getting fresh and healthy meals that are good for them.

• Recipe Variety – For dog owners with picky eaters like me, you want to have a variety of recipes to offer your pooch. This can keep them guessing and motivated at mealtime.

• Expert Input – Pet parents that try to eat a healthy diet want to be sure their dogs are doing the same. By using vet nutritionists, you can have peace of mind knowing that these meals are complete and balanced.

• Packaging And Preparation – It’s vital that your meals arrive in good shape with their integrity preserved. If you’ve signed up for this service, it’s important that serving up these meals is easy and efficient.

• Ordering Experience – Not everyone is technology savvy, so it’s important that dog food delivery companies have an easy and simple ordering process.

• Price – Dog food delivery companies provide a premium service. So you should expect to dig a little deeper in your pockets to finance this subscription plan.

• Delivery Schedule – Sometimes life can get in the way. So it’s important that these companies can be flexible with their deliveries. Most will give you the ability to pause or cancel at any time.

A Pup Above vs The Farmer’s Dog – Our Recommendation

It’s time to make a decision: which dog food delivery company do we prefer?

We are impressed with both A Pup Above and The Farmer’s Dog, especially their quality of their ingredients and variety recipe.

However, we believe A Pup Above have the slight edge.

We found their sous-vide cooking method a really unique approach. It’s a selling point that a lot of other dog food delivery companies don’t have.

If you’ve got fussy or picky eaters like my Alaskan Klee Kai dogs, you’ll know how important it is that their meals have lots of flavour to pique their interest.

We like how A Pup Above have also considered freezer space. Signing up to a dog food delivery company can often leave your freezer space at a premium. But you won’t have to worry about that with A Pup Above’s balanced and complete dog food.

Having said all that, we do think The Farmer’s Dog offer a really good service. We like their rip-and-serve packaging, which certainly makes life extremely easy.

While we don’t think you’ll go wrong if you choose The Farmer’s Dog, we believe A Pup Above have a couple of unique selling points and that’s we rate them as the number one option here.

What Are Customers Saying About A Pup Above And The Farmer’s Dog?

A Pup Above have a review section on their website that has 78 reviews. They’re seems to be a lot of satisfied pooches.

One MiKi owner revealed the impact their meals have had on her little dog’s life:

My 6lb MiKi is the pickiest eater I’ve ever had. After going to the expense of trying several of the better fresh diets, I finally found a fresh diet in A Pup Above that he loves and eats readily- and has not tired of the taste! I alternate between the beef and the pork so that he doesn’t get “burned out”, which he’s done before. Thank you, GrocerRead more about review stating A Pup Above Beef and Porky Pup, for solving my picky eater’s appetite!

Another pet parent with a picky pup revealed the transformation that A Pup Above triggered:

My picky pup had just about stopped eating his food- that is, until A Pup Above arrived at our door. You know how excited your pup gets for a walk? It’s that level for him every time I pull out a bag from the fridge. I love that I can see real, hearty ingredients in the mix, instead of just brown balls or mush. Energy levels are higher, tummy is healthier, and, most importantly, pup is happier. I’m sold for life.

The Farmer’s Dog has a rating of 4.9 out of 6 stars based upon nearly 700 reviews on Google.

A pet parent with two dogs was thrilled to see her pooches motivated at mealtime:

Our dogs, Stella and Alan (both Chihuahua/Terrier mixes) dove right in and loved Farmer’s Dog foods from day one. It was exciting for us since they were such finicky eaters before, no matter what we gave them. Different story with Farmer’s Dog, for sure.

Preston, a Mini Doodle, is excited about his food after making the switch:

Preston is the sweetest and happiest one year old mini golden doodle. But he never loved eating his meals. His kibble would be left in the bowl. So we decided to try the Farmer’s Dog and it was the best thing we did for him. He LOVES his meals and gobbles it all up. On top of it all, we are so comforted knowing we are giving him healthy food full of fresh ingredients and nutrients catered to his special “chicken allergy/chicken free” diet!

A Pup Above Or The Farmer’s Dog Coupon Code Or Discount?

A Pup Above have an offer available to new customers.

Our readers can can get 25% off their first A Pup Above order when they sign up to a subscription plan using the HELLOBARK25 coupon code at the checkout. Click here to subscribe now!

Anything Else To Consider?

We recommend talking to your vet before you decide to change your dog’s diet. They can give you the steps to follow to gradually introduce a new type of food to your furry friend.

If you make the change too fast, your dog could suffer with an upset stomach leading to diarrhea or vomiting. Usually, it’s recommended your introduce the new food over a period of one to two weeks.

Here’s some advice from A Pup Above about making the transition:

Making the switch to a new food is a gradual process for many pups that typically takes 7-10 days. A new diet causes disruption of the good bugs in your dog’s gut – called the microbiome – but if you take your time, their microbiome will adapt.

Wrapping Things Up – Final Thoughts

A Pup Above (Photo: apupabove.com)

A Pup Above (Photo: apupabove.com)

We’ve reached the end of our A Pup Above vs The Farmer’s Dog comparison article.

These two companies are both aiming to give pet parents in the USA a fresh alternative for their dog meals.

They use human grade ingredients that are fresh and healthy, free from any potential additives or nasties.

We’ve opted for A Pup Above over The Farmer’s Dog.

A Pup Above use a sous-vide cooking method to retain their nutrients and provide lots of flavour.

Whether you go for A Pup Above or The Farmer’s Dog, you can’t go too far wrong. But we believe A Pup Above have a slight edge.

Best dog food delivery
We've picked out eight dog food delivery companies that can provide your pet with complete, balanced and fresh meals